Butterfinger's layered, crumbly centre isn't a happy accident of chocolate-bar manufacturing — it's a deliberately laminated peanut-butter-and-toffee mixture, built up in thin sheets and then broken apart before coating.
Where Butterfinger actually came from
Butterfinger was created in 1923 by the Curtiss Candy Company of Chicago, the same company founded by Otto Schnering that had launched the Baby Ruth bar a couple of years earlier. The name reportedly came out of a promotional contest, and the bar was pitched from the start as something texturally different from the smooth nougat bars already crowding US candy counters — one of the best-known names in American candy ever since.
How the flaky centre is actually made
- The mixture — a peanut-butter-and-toffee blend is worked and pulled rather than simply poured.
- The lamination — it's built up in thin layers, similar in principle to puff pastry, rather than set as one solid block.
- The shatter — once set, the laminated block is broken into pieces, which is exactly why a bite gives you that crumbly, flaky crunch rather than a clean cut.
- The coating — the broken pieces are then coated in a layer of chocolate, sealing in the crunch.
Who's owned it, and the Simpsons years
Butterfinger stayed with Nestlé for decades after Nestlé acquired the Curtiss Candy Company's brands, and became one of the most heavily advertised bars in the US during the 1990s thanks to a long-running Bart Simpson campaign built around the line "nobody better lay a finger on my Butterfinger." Nestlé sold most of its US confectionery business, Butterfinger included, to the Italian company Ferrero in 2018, which still owns and produces it today.
Frequently asked questions
Who invented Butterfinger and when?
Butterfinger was created in 1923 by the Curtiss Candy Company of Chicago, founded by Otto Schnering — the same company behind the Baby Ruth bar.
What makes Butterfinger's texture different from other chocolate bars?
Butterfinger's center is a laminated, flaky peanut-butter-and-toffee mixture rather than a solid nougat or caramel — thin layers are built up and then shattered into the crunchy, crumbly texture the bar is known for, coated in a layer of chocolate.
Who owns Butterfinger now?
Butterfinger was owned by Nestlé for decades before being sold, along with most of Nestlé's US confectionery business, to Ferrero in 2018.