For about two years, there was no blue Smartie — and it wasn't a flavour decision. It came down to one difficult colour and a promise Nestlé had made about what it would and wouldn't put in the tube.
A pledge Nestlé couldn't quite keep on day one
Nestlé committed to removing artificial colours from Smarties. Natural replacements were found for red, green, yellow, orange and the rest — but blue was the holdout. There wasn't yet a natural colouring that could reliably produce it, so rather than break the no-artificial-colours pledge for one shade, Nestlé dropped the blue Smartie entirely in 2006 and added a white one in its place to keep the tube's piece count the same.
The comeback: spirulina
The fix turned out to be spirulina, a natural extract from blue-green algae, which could stand in for the artificial dye Brilliant Blue (E133) that had coloured the original. Blue Smarties returned to UK shelves in February 2008, after roughly two years away — Nestlé's own line has always been that the removal was meant to be temporary, with the intention to bring blue back as soon as a natural option existed.
Other markets moved on their own schedule: in Canada, artificial colouring wasn't dropped until 2009, with blue Smarties reappearing there in 2010.
What we actually stock
We carry the Smarties Milk Chocolate Tube 38g, also available as a price-marked pack and as a 3-pack multipack — all with the full colour line-up, blue included.
Frequently asked questions
Why did Smarties remove the blue one?
Nestlé had pledged to use only natural colourings, and couldn't find one for blue in time, so it dropped the colour in 2006 and added a white Smartie instead.
When did blue Smarties come back?
February 2008 in the UK, once a natural blue colouring was found.
What colours blue Smarties now?
Spirulina, a natural blue-green algae extract, in place of the artificial dye Brilliant Blue (E133).
Does Supreme Sweets stock Smarties?
Yes — the Smarties Milk Chocolate Tube, in single packs and a 3-pack multipack.