White chocolate's place in the chocolate family gets argued about constantly, and the UK's own labelling law is actually on the sceptics' side. It's legally allowed to be sold as chocolate while containing none of the ingredient that gives chocolate its flavour and colour.
What's actually required by law
Under the Cocoa and Chocolate Products Regulations 2003, white chocolate must contain at least 20% cocoa butter and at least 14% dry milk solids, of which at least 3.5% has to be milk fat. That's the entire compositional requirement — there's no minimum for non-fat cocoa solids at all.
Why that detail actually matters
Cocoa butter is just the fat pressed out of the cocoa bean — pale, mild, and largely flavourless on its own. The part that carries the bean's characteristic chocolate flavour and brown colour is the non-fat cocoa solids, the ground cocoa mass left once the butter is separated out. Milk chocolate's legal definition requires at least 25% total dry cocoa solids (which includes a non-fat cocoa solids minimum), and dark chocolate's requires at least 35%. White chocolate's definition skips that requirement entirely, which is the technical basis for the long-running argument that it isn't 'real' chocolate in the way milk and dark are.
What we actually stock right now
We currently stock Milkybar Buttons White Chocolate Bag 30g, in stock and ready to ship, if you want to taste the difference for yourself against a milk or dark bar.
Frequently asked questions
Does white chocolate have to contain cocoa solids?
No — only a cocoa butter minimum, with no requirement for non-fat cocoa solids.
What's the legal minimum for white chocolate?
At least 20% cocoa butter and 14% dry milk solids under UK regulations.
Why does that make people say it isn't 'real' chocolate?
Because the flavour- and colour-carrying part of the bean, non-fat cocoa solids, isn't required at all — unlike milk and dark chocolate.
Related reading
For how milk and dark chocolate's percentages compare to each other, see our guide to milk vs dark chocolate percentages.